Shopping for a new toilet isn’t as simple as walking into the hardware store and picking the first one that looks nice. A toilet is one of the hardest-working fixtures in your bathroom, with a lifespan that often stretches beyond a decade. The one you choose will affect not only your everyday comfort but also how easy your bathroom is to clean, how much water you save, and even the overall style of the space.
With so many choices—two-piece or one-piece, floor-mounted or wall-hung, traditional or smart—it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. So, how do you figure out which toilet checks all the boxes for your home? That’s exactly what this guide is here to help with. We’ll break down the different options, explain what really matters, and give you the tools to make a confident choice.
Step 1: Three Things to Do Before You Shop
Before you jump onto that shopping app or head to the showroom, it’s worth tackling a few basics first. Laying this groundwork will save you from 80% of the common mistakes homeowners make when buying a new toilet.
Measure Your Bathroom’s Key Dimensions
- Rough-In Distance
This is the space from the finished wall to the center of the toilet’s waste outlet, and it’s the single most important measurement. In most U.S. homes, the standard rough-in is 12", though you’ll also find 10" and 14" setups—especially in older houses. Always measure from the finished wall (tiles included) and remember to account for any waterproofing layers, which can add about ¼"–½".
- Width Clearance
You’ll want at least 8" of clearance between the toilet tank and any side wall or cabinet. Without enough space, your elbows may bump into the wall during use, and cleaning will be a headache.
- Seat Height
Toilet seats typically range from 14.5" to 21" in height. For seniors, children, or anyone with mobility challenges, ADA-compliant models (17"–19") are usually the most comfortable and make standing up easier.
Confirm the Drainage Type
- Floor Outlet
This is the standard in most U.S. homes, where the waste pipe connects through the floor. Be sure your new toilet matches your rough-in measurement.
- Wall Outlet
Used for wall-hung toilets, this setup places the waste pipe inside the wall. Keep in mind it requires specialized, in-wall plumbing.
Understand Installation Requirements
- Wall Strength
Wall-hung toilets need an in-wall carrier and tank. The wall should be reinforced concrete or another load-bearing structure, capable of supporting at least 880 lbs. Hollow brick walls may need added steel framing; otherwise, the toilet could eventually loosen or detach.
- Plumbing and Electrical Setup
If you’re considering a smart toilet, you’ll need a nearby GFCI-protected outlet (within about 12") that supplies a stable 110V current. Wall-hung models also require careful plumbing work during construction—retrofitting later can be expensive and complicated.
Step 2: Comparing Toilet Types
Not all toilets are created equal. The style you choose will affect not just how your bathroom looks, but also how easy the toilet is to install, maintain, and use day to day. A good starting point is to figure out which type best suits your space and lifestyle—then narrow it down by brand and features.
Here’s a breakdown of the four most common options:
| Type | Key Advantages | Best For | Considerations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Two-Piece | Budget-friendly ($70–$210), lighter weight, easier to transport | Rental properties, older homes, homeowners looking to save | The seam between the tank and bowl can collect grime and may eventually leak |
| One-Piece | Sleek, seamless design that’s easier to clean and looks more modern | New builds, bathroom remodels, families who value style and function | Heavier (70–120 lbs), usually requires two people for installation |
| Wall-Hung | Saves floor space, creates a minimalist look, leaves room underneath for cleaning | Compact bathrooms, contemporary interiors | Needs an in-wall carrier system; servicing the tank may require opening the wall |
| Smart Toilet | Premium features like heated seats, bidet washing, and warm air drying | Households seeking maximum comfort, seniors, improved hygiene | Requires a nearby power outlet; higher upfront and maintenance costs |
Step 3: Key Performance Features to Look For
Once you’ve picked the toilet style that fits your bathroom, it’s time to focus on performance. These features directly affect comfort, cleaning ease, and how long your toilet will last.
Flushing System: Say Goodbye to Weak Flushes and Noise
- Siphon Flush
Uses negative pressure for a strong yet quiet flush (≤55 dB) and better odor control. Works especially well in master bathrooms. Tankless requires water pressure of at least 29 psi; if your home has low water pressure, consider pressure-assisted models instead.
- Washdown (Direct Flush)
Delivers a strong water impact to prevent clogs—perfect if your bathroom is far from the main drain. On the downside, it’s louder (≥65 dB) and offers weaker odor control.
- Flush Buttons
Opt for dual-flush toilets: a small flush (0.8–1.0 GPF) for liquid waste and a large flush (1.3–1.6 GPF) for solids. Dual-flush models save water and lower your utility bills compared with single-flush toilets.
Glaze Quality: The Secret to Easy Cleaning
- Why It Matters
Poor glaze yellows over time, stains easily, and makes scrubbing a daily chore.
- High-Quality Glaze
Smooth and glass-like, free of pinholes or scratches, and feels silky to the touch.
- Advanced Options
Microcrystal Self-Cleaning Glaze: Helps prevent stains from sticking.
Nano-Antibacterial Glaze: Slows bacterial growth—great for homes with kids.
Quick Test: Drop a few drops of water on the surface. A high-quality glaze will make the water bead and roll off.
Seat Design: Comfort Matters
- Material
Polypropylene (PP) seats are durable and resist aging. High-end PP options with antibacterial treatment help reduce germs.
- Shape
Ergonomic, contoured seats provide better support and comfort for longer sitting.
- Bowl Width
Typically 9–13 inches. Too narrow can feel cramped; too wide may waste space.
Water Efficiency: Save Hundreds Every Year
- Regulation
U.S. law limits flush volume to 1.6 GPF or less.
- Best Choice
Look for WaterSense-labeled toilets (≤1.3 GPF), which can save roughly 2,325 gallons of water annually.
Warning: Be cautious with ultra-low flush models (e.g., 0.8 GPF). They may not clear waste completely, causing repeated flushing and higher water usage. Always check flushing performance before you buy.
Step 4: Special Considerations for Smart Toilets
Smart toilets are packed with features, but more isn’t always better. The key is to focus on what you’ll actually use every day rather than being distracted by every gadget.
Must-Have Features
- Heated Seat: Look for adjustable settings (usually 3–5 levels) for cozy comfort during winter.
- Cleansing Modes: Rear wash and feminine wash are standard. For women, a gentle pulsating spray is ideal during menstruation or postpartum recovery.
- Warm Air Dryer: Adjustable temperature (typically 86°F–122°F) reduces toilet paper use and adds a spa-like experience.
Nice-to-Have Features
- Automatic Lid/Seat: Opens and closes with a motion sensor. This is convenient for hygiene, but check the sensitivity in smaller bathrooms to avoid accidental triggers.
- Deodorizer: Built-in activated carbon or ion filters remove odors quickly—especially helpful in bathrooms with poor ventilation.
- Water Filtration: Pre-filters protect spray nozzles from mineral buildup, extending the life of the system.
Things to Watch Out For
- Power Supply: Choose plug-in models with stable performance. Battery-only options can run out mid-use. Always make sure the outlet is GFCI-protected for safety.
- Backup Options: Check for a manual flush or battery backup so the toilet remains usable during power outages.
-
After-Sales Support: Smart toilets combine electronics and mechanics, so a solid warranty is essential. Look for brands offering at least 2 years of coverage, such as Kohler, TOTO, or Giving Tree Home. If you’re unsure, guide “Best Smart Toilet Brands” in the World can be helpful.
Ending
Choosing the right toilet is about more than just style or price—it’s about comfort, efficiency, and long-term satisfaction. By measuring your space, understanding different types of toilets, evaluating performance features, and considering the special requirements of smart models, you can make a choice that enhances your daily life for years to come.
If you’re still unsure about which toilet is best for your home—or where to find reliable, high-quality options—Giving Tree Home is a trusted choice. Our expert team can guide you through selecting the perfect toilet that fits your bathroom, budget, and lifestyle. And if you have any questions along the way, our online support and email team are always ready to assist. We’re committed to helping you make a confident, informed decision and ensuring your bathroom is both functional and stylish.
